The Supreme Court of Iowa recently dismissed a case concerning education standards, saying the matter would be better resolved by legislators.
A lawsuit filed in 2008 alleged that education in the state is unequal and that schools with 250 or fewer students are commonly at a disadvantage, violating students' right to an equal education regardless of where in the state they live. The court ruled that the district judge who previously dismissed the case was correct to do so, noting that Iowa's education law does not expressly mandate free public schooling be made available to all children.
This case was an unprecedented one, according to plaintiffs' attorney Doug Gross, because the state Supreme Court has never before been required to interpret the education clause. The lawsuit sought to force officials to close achievement gaps between school districts, among other changes.
The justices who voted to dismiss the case largely did so because they felt the court was not the appropriate body to address the issue, according to their written opinions. Had the court ruled otherwise, it might have led to major efforts being required from officials. As matters stand, some indicated the case is a call to action despite the ruling, so it may yet provoke change.
